• AA Literature
    • A.A. Big Book
      • A.A. Big Book (164 Pages)
      • Big Book Stories Edition 1
      • Big Book Stories Edition 2
    • A.A. Preamble
    • Singleness of Purpose
    • A.A. 12 Steps
    • A.A. 12 Traditions
    • A.A. 12 Concepts
    • 12 Traditions Checklist
    • 9th Step Promises (Pg 83/84)
    • The Serenity Prayer
    • Principles Of The Program
    • I Am Responsible
    • The Page Of Prayers
  • A.A. History
    • The Emmanuel Movement
    • The Washingtonians
    • Magazine & Newspaper Articles
    • Narrative Of A.A. Timeline
    • Timelines In A.A. History
    • Manuscript Of A.A. World History – Bob P.
    • Place And Things In AA History
    • Who’s Who In A.A. History
    • Big Book Story Authors
    • Writings Of A.A. Members
  • Influential Books
    • A.A. Big Book (164 Pages)
    • Big Book Stories Edition 1
    • Big Book Stories Edition 2
    • Mel B’s Library
    • Dick B.’s Library
    • The Greatest Thing In The World
    • The Varieties Of Religious Experiences
    • In His Steps
    • As A Man Thinketh
    • When Man Listens
    • John Barleycorn
    • The Confessions Of Saint Augustine (13 Books)
    • Religion, Clergy & A.A.
  • Free Stuff
    • Free Audiobooks & Speaker Tapes
    • Videos Of Bill Wilson
    • The PDF Project (1000+ PDF’s)
    • Free AA Apps For iPhone
    • Free AA Apps For Android
    • Free 12 Step Toolkit App
  • AA Literature
    • A.A. Big Book
      • A.A. Big Book (164 Pages)
      • Big Book Stories Edition 1
      • Big Book Stories Edition 2
    • A.A. Preamble
    • Singleness of Purpose
    • A.A. 12 Steps
    • A.A. 12 Traditions
    • A.A. 12 Concepts
    • 12 Traditions Checklist
    • 9th Step Promises (Pg 83/84)
    • The Serenity Prayer
    • Principles Of The Program
    • I Am Responsible
    • The Page Of Prayers
  • A.A. History
    • The Emmanuel Movement
    • The Washingtonians
    • Magazine & Newspaper Articles
    • Narrative Of A.A. Timeline
    • Timelines In A.A. History
    • Manuscript Of A.A. World History – Bob P.
    • Place And Things In AA History
    • Who’s Who In A.A. History
    • Big Book Story Authors
    • Writings Of A.A. Members
  • Influential Books
    • A.A. Big Book (164 Pages)
    • Big Book Stories Edition 1
    • Big Book Stories Edition 2
    • Mel B’s Library
    • Dick B.’s Library
    • The Greatest Thing In The World
    • The Varieties Of Religious Experiences
    • In His Steps
    • As A Man Thinketh
    • When Man Listens
    • John Barleycorn
    • The Confessions Of Saint Augustine (13 Books)
    • Religion, Clergy & A.A.
  • Free Stuff
    • Free Audiobooks & Speaker Tapes
    • Videos Of Bill Wilson
    • The PDF Project (1000+ PDF’s)
    • Free AA Apps For iPhone
    • Free AA Apps For Android
    • Free 12 Step Toolkit App
home/Alcoholics Anonymous/Other Articles/Religion, Clergy & A.A.

01-005 Some Dangers In Alcoholics Anonymous, By Paul L. O’Connor, S.J. Ecclesiastical Review, Vol. 106: 285-288, April, 1942

129 views 0 aa

ECCLESIASTICAL REVIEW, Vol. 106: 285-288, April, 1942

SOME DANGERS IN ALCOHOLICS ANONYMOUS
By Paul L. O’Connor, S.J.

Dr. Braceland in his article “Psychiatric Aspects of Chronic Alcoholism,” in the Ecclesiastical Review for December, 1941, recommended that the the priest who, in line of duty, comes into contact with cases of acute alcoholism, should investigate the working of the group called Alcoholics Anonymous. Any priest who investigates that group will be astonished at the success it has achieved in the permanent cure of seemingly inveterate alcoholics. He may feel justified, on the strength of that record, in summoning the members of that group and handing his patient over to them. Before he does this he should realize fully the dangers to faith inherent in the method of Alcoholics Anonymous and at least be prepared to counteract these dangers.

As Dr. Braceland pointed out, Alcoholics Anonymous claim that they appeal to a man’s religious sense but do not interfere with his belief. That distinction is, I think, too fine for practical experiment. It seems to be an impossibility to work in the vague realm of religious sense and still leave a man’s faith strictly alone. The thing smacks of Protestant endeavors like the Y.M.C.A.

Alcoholics Anonymous say officially that they have no connection with any organized religion, and there is no reason for thinking they are not sincere in this statement. Whether they realize it or not, their methods are shot through with the methods of Buchmanism or the Oxford Peace Movement or whatever you care to call that much publicized revival movement that swept across the country several years ago and finally blew itself out some miles west of Hollywood. Buchmanism, also, appealed to a man’s religious sense and did not interfere with his belief – as long as he believed in Buchmanism.

The fact that Alcoholics Anonymous is a group of reformed alcoholics who, without even the reward of publicity, work with others who have fallen victim to this disease, is well known. Their program of rehabilitation is not so well known. When their patient is painfully recovering from his latest spree and when, finally admitting that he has failed to cure himself, he sincerely desires help from this group, the following program is outlined to him.

1. You cannot cure yourself. You must have supreme confidence in some Power greater than yourself. How you define this Power does not matter at all. You must effect a conscious relation with this God, as you understand Him, whether it be as a Creative Intelligence or as a Spirit of the Universe or whatever you care to make Him. As soon as you do this you will find that a new power, a new peace and sense of direction will flow into you. You will find this God deep within you, for in the last analysis that is only where He may be found. He will restore you to sanity.

2. You must make a searching and fearless moral inventory of yourself, listing all your faults and grievances.

3. You must admit to God, to yourself, and to another human being the exact nature of your faults, and must humbly ask God to help you remove these defects of character.

4. You must make a list of all persons you have harmed, have the intention of making amends to all, and whenever possible make these amends.

5. You must completely renounce alcohol in any form.

6. You must continue, through prayer and meditation, to improve your contact with God, praying for knowledge and for power to continue carrying out His will.

7. Once reformed, you must work with alcoholics in effecting their renovation.

The priest should be especially wary of the dangers that lie hidden in points 1, 3, and 7. They are not insurmountable, but they are very real dangers.

The Catholic who is striving to recover from alcoholism is at a definitely critical point in his career. If, with the help of his religion and the sacraments, he conquers this vice, he is well on the way to becoming a staunch, active Catholic. But if at that critical time he is told again and again, as he will be told by the Alcoholics Anonymous, that it makes absolutely no difference what he believes as long as he believes in some Power greater than himself, and then recovers, he is not going to have a great deal of use for Catholic dogma and what will appear to him to be the Catholic boast of, “we have God’s grace on our side.”

This difficulty might be obviated if the priest himself, or better yet, a Catholic member of Alcoholics Anonymous, work with the alcoholic, leave out the generalities of “Power greater than himself,” and fed him the strong Catholic stuff of “God, the loving Father, Jesus Christ, the God man and model, the Holy Spirit, the source of strengthening grace.”

Secondly, the confession required can be a source of grave scandal if made to a private individual or to a group. Here again the Catholic can be offered the Sacrament of Penance and the consequent sacramental grace in addition to psychiatric healing. The danger does not cease once the alcoholic is cured. He is then advised to attend informal meetings of Alcoholics Anonymous, and there discuss quite frankly his former sorry state and consequent vagaries.

Thirdly, the reformed alcoholics work with patients, while it has proved highly successful in keeping him on the straight and narrow, is for the Catholic bristling with dangers to his faith. No man, even one well grounded in his faith, can argue long and earnestly with an agnostic or a heretic, assuring him constantly that it makes no difference what he believes as long as he puts himself in the hands of one stronger than himself, and still stand fast to the doctrine of the One True Church. Temptations to faith are one of the two temptations where the best defense is hasty flight.

The very essence of the technique of this organization is the surrendering of the will to some Superior Being in order that He or It may direct their whole lives. When the Catholic sees that the Universal Intelligence of the Pantheist or the Inspiration of the Christian Scientist seems to be doing just as good a job as his own God, the doubt will easily arise, “Perhaps it doesn’t make any difference just what you believe.”

The antidote might be for the priest to recommend Catholics to work with other Catholics. Here he would be up against the organization’s recommendation of helping anyone whenever that help is needed, which at first blush looks much like true Christ like charity.

These few warnings are by no means a condemnation of Alcoholics Anonymous. Their work is good work and one sorely needed today. Their results are enviable. Their methods can be baptized. Dr Braceland’s recommendation, that the priest investigate Alcoholics Anonymous still stands. They are anxious to work with priests and they can be reached in most large cities through doctors or hospitals. The priest, before he releases any patient to them, however, should be well aware of the dangers present in such a cure, and should be prepared to take precautionary measures.

Tags:aaalcoholics anonymousother articlesreligion clergy and aa1942

Was this helpful?

Yes  No
Related Articles
  • 01-108 Liberation Spirituality: 60 Years Of A.A., By Neil J. Carr. America, Vol. 172(21), 20-22, June 17, 1995
  • 01-107 Dethroning King Alcohol: Spiritual Steps To Freedom, By Ruth Gledhill. The Tablet, Vol. 249, 104-107, January 28, 1995
  • 01-106 12 Step Programs Work For Many, Not All, By Dawn Gibeau. National Catholic Reporter, Vol. 38: 25, January 21, 1994
  • 01-105 The Clergy’s Role In A.A.’s Fifth Step, By Jack O’Neill. The Priest, Vol. 49: 19-20, March, 1993
  • 01-104 The Spirituality Of Surrender, By John P. Mossi. Review For Religious, Vol. 52: 842-848, Nov./Dec., 1993
  • 01-103 Addiction, Recovery And God, By Irving B. Mace. Living Prayer, Vol. 26(1): 26-26, Jan./Feb., 1993
Popular Articles
  • L’Importance Du Groupe D’Attache (French)
  • Chapter III – Of The Darkness Upon The Deep, And Of The Invisible And Formless Earth.
  • Dr. Alex Kileforth, Drs Convention Greensboro Hotel Springs, West Virginia, 1963
  • Intergroups
  • A Life Synthesis
KB Categories
  • Literature 12
    • Big Book 18
    • Big Book Stories Edition 1 29
    • Big Book Stories Edition 2 40
    • A.A. Prayers 10
    • The Big Book Concordance 27
    • The Original Manuscript Of AA. 16
    • The First A.A. Pamphlet 8
  • Writings Of A.A. Members 0
    • Bill W. 19
      • Let's Ask Bill W. 41
      • Bill W. On The 12 Traditions 16
      • Letters – To Jim Burwell From Bill Wilson 18
      • Letters – To Bill Wilson From Jim Burwell 3
      • Talks At General Service Conferences 31
        • Alcoholic Foundation 4
      • Grapevine Articles Of Bill W. 34
        • Grapevine – 12 Traditions Of A.A. 16
        • Grapevine – 12 Steps Of AA 2
    • Lois W. 7
    • Doctor Bob 10
    • Henry G. (Hank P. 2
    • Clarence S. 6
    • Bill D. 2
    • Ebby Thacher 2
    • Others 13
      • Letters – To Jim Burwell From Bill Wilson 18
      • Letters – To Bill Wilson From Jim Burwell 3
  • Al-Anon 14
  • Research & Study 14
    • Dr. William Duncan Silkworth M.D. 12
      • Grapevine Articles Of Dr. William Silkworth 5
    • A Narrative Of Timeline Of A.A. History 30
    • Timelines In A.A. History 14
    • Timelines Of Historic A.A. Events 1
    • Manuscript Of A.A. World History, 1985 – By Bob P. 23
    • Magazine And Newspaper Articles 149
    • People In A.A.'s History 26
    • Place And Things In AA History 13
    • The Washingtonians 31
      • Grapevine Articles Of The Washingtonians 15
    • The Emmanuel Movement 12
    • Big Book Story Author's 78
    • Whos's Who In A.A.'s History 23
    • Big Book Changes 1
    • Tiebout Papers 6
    • AA Growth 135
    • Charlie Bishop Jr. 3
    • A.A. History – News Articles 8
      • Cleveland Plain Dealer 8
    • Gresham's Law And Alcoholics Anonymous 5
    • Stepping Stone News 1
  • The PDF Project (1000+ PDF's 1
    • The Big Book (179 Articles 6
    • Bill W. (172 Articles 4
    • Dr. Bob (24 Articles 1
    • General Service Conference (157 Articles 6
    • Grapevine (51 Articles 5
    • History (437 Articles 52
  • Audio Books 0
    • Joe & Charlie 34
    • AA Big Book Audiobook 14
    • Sandy B. – Saturday Morning Live 12
    • AA Speaker Bill W. 100
    • Videos 15
    • International Conventions – 2015 184
    • AA Speaker Chuck C. 111
    • AA Speakers Clergy 220
    • AA Speakers Doctor's 129
    • AA Speaker Sandy B. 74
    • AA Assorted Speakers 195
  • Other Articles 40
    • Printed Book Reviews 26
    • Religion, Clergy & A.A. 108
  • Influential Books 0
    • Big Book Of AA 21
    • Personal Stories – Edition 1 29
    • Personal Stories – Edition 2 40
    • Mel B.'s Library 56
      • The Four Absolutes 17
    • Dick B.'s Library 128
    • The Greatest Thing In The world 5
    • In His Steps 32
    • The Varieties Of Religious Experiences 17
    • As A Man Thinketh 8
    • When Man Listens 6
    • The Confessions Of Saint Augustine 5
      • Book One 20
      • Book Two 12
      • Book Three 14
      • Book Four 18
      • Book Five 16
      • Book Six 18
      • Book Seven 23
      • Book Eight 14
      • Book Nine 15
      • Book Ten 45
      • Book Eleven 33
      • Book Twelve 34
      • Book Thirteen 40
    • Other Books 9
    • John Barleycorn 39
  • Grapevine Articles 4
    • Grapevine Reproduction 8
    • Additional A.A. Grapevine Articles 20
    • Big Book Updates 13
    • Other Grapevine Articles 33
    • Grapevine Articles – Interviews 6
  • The Detroit Pamphlet 4
  • A.A. History – General 27
  • The History Of Alcoholics Anonymous 6
  • The Global Map 3
    • Africa 0
      • Algeria & Morocco 1
      • Angola & Zambia 1
      • Burkina Faso & Mali 1
      • Cameroon 1
      • Central African Republic & Ethiopia 1
      • Comoro Island & Seychelles 1
      • Congo & Gabon 1
      • Cote d'Ivoire & Guinea 1
      • Egypt 1
      • Eritrea & Djibouti 1
      • Ghana, Togo & Benin 1
      • Guinea-Bissau & The Gambia 1
      • Liberia & Sierra Leone 1
      • Libya & Tunisia 1
      • Madagascar 1
      • Malawi & Zimbabwe 1
      • Mauritania & Western Sahara 1
      • Namibia & Botswana 1
      • Nigeria & Niger 1
      • Reunion & Mauritius 1
      • Rwanda & Burundi 1
      • Saint Helena & Equatorial Guinea 1
      • Sao Tome & Principe 1
      • Senegal & Cape Verde 1
      • Somalia 1
      • South Africa & Lesotho 1
      • Sudan & Chad 1
      • Swaziland & Mozambique 1
      • Tanzania & D. R. Congo 1
      • Uganda & Kenya 1
    • Asia 0
      • Bangladesh 1
      • Burma 1
      • Bhutan 1
      • China 1
      • Hong Kong 1
      • India 1
      • Indonesia 1
      • Japan 1
      • Kazakhstan 1
      • Laos 1
      • Malaysia 1
      • Maldives 1
      • Mongolia 1
      • North Korea 1
      • Nepal 1
      • Pakistan 1
      • Philippines 1
      • Russia 2
      • South Korea 1
      • Sri Lanka 1
      • Thailand 1
      • Taiwan 1
      • Vietnam 1
    • Canada 0
      • Alberta 1
      • British Columbia 2
      • Manitoba 1
      • New Brunswick 1
      • Newfoundland 1
      • Northwest Territories 1
      • Nova Scotia 1
      • Ontario 18
      • Quebec 1
      • Saskatchewan 1
      • Yukon 1
    • Caribbean 0
      • Anguilla 1
      • Antiqua 1
      • Aruba 1
      • Bonaire 1
      • Barbados 1
      • Barbuda 1
      • Bahamas 1
      • Bermuda 1
      • Cuba 1
      • Cayman Island 1
      • Curacao 1
      • Dominican Republic 1
      • Dominica 1
      • Grenada 1
      • Guadeloupe 1
      • Haiti 1
      • Jamaica 1
      • Margarita 1
      • Martinique 1
      • Puerto Rico 1
      • Saint Maarten/Saint Martin 1
      • Saint Barts 1
      • Saint Lucia 1
      • Saint Vincent And The Grenadines 1
      • Saba/Saint Eustatius 1
      • Saint Kitts And Nevis 1
      • Trinidad And Tobago 1
      • Turks And Caicos 1
      • Virgin Islands 1
    • Central America 0
      • Belize 1
      • Costa Rica 1
      • El Salvador 1
      • Guatemala 1
      • Honduras 1
      • Mexico 1
      • Nicaragua 1
      • Panama 1
    • Europe 0
      • Austria 1
      • Andorra 1
      • Belgium 1
      • Bulgaria 1
      • Croatia.html 1
      • Cyprus 1
      • Czech Republic 1
      • Denmark 1
      • Estonia 1
      • England 2
      • Finland 1
      • France 1
      • Germany 1
      • Greece 1
      • Gibraltar 1
      • Hungary 1
      • Herzegovina 1
      • Iceland 1
      • Ireland 1
      • Italy 1
      • Latvia 1
      • Liechtenstein 1
      • Lithuania 1
      • Luxembourg 1
      • Malta 1
      • Macedonia 1
      • Monaco 1
      • Netherlands 1
      • Norway 1
      • Poland 1
      • Portugal 1
      • Romania 1
      • Russia 2
      • Scotland 2
      • Slovakia 1
      • Slovenia 1
      • Spain 1
      • Sweden 1
      • Switzerland 1
      • Turkey 1
      • Ukraine 1
      • Wales 1
      • Yugoslavia 1
    • Middle East 0
      • Arabia 1
      • Azerbaijan 1
      • Armenia 1
      • Afghanistan 1
      • Bahrain 1
      • Cyprus 1
      • Iran 1
      • Iraq 1
      • Israel 1
      • Jordan 1
      • Kuwait 1
      • Kyrgyzstan 1
      • Lebanon 1
      • Oman 1
      • Qatar 1
      • Syria 1
      • Saudi Arabia 1
      • Tajikistan 1
      • Turkmenistan 1
      • Turkey 1
      • United Arab Emirates 1
      • Yemen 1
    • Australia (Oceania 0
      • Australia 3
      • American Samoa 1
      • Cook Islands 1
      • Coral Sea Islands 1
      • Federated States Of Micronesia 1
      • Fiji 1
      • French Polynesia 1
      • Guam 1
      • Kiribati 1
      • Marshall Islands 1
      • Northern Mariana Islands 1
      • New Zealand 1
      • Nauru 1
      • New Caledonia 1
      • Niue 1
      • Palau 1
      • Papua New Guinea 1
      • Pitcairn Islands 1
      • Solomon Islands 1
      • Tongi 1
      • Tokelau 1
      • Tuvalu 1
      • Vanuatu 1
      • Western Samoa 1
      • Wallis And Futuna Islands 1
    • South America 0
      • Aruba (NL 1
      • Argentina 1
      • Bolivia 1
      • Brazil 1
      • Chile 1
      • Ecuador 1
      • French Guiana (France 1
      • Falkland Islands (UK 1
      • Guyana 1
      • Netherland Antilles (NL 1
      • Peru 1
      • Paraguay 1
      • Suriname 1
      • South Georgia (UK 1
      • Uruguay 1
      • Venezuela 1
    • United States 0
      • Alabama 1
      • Alaska 1
      • Arizona 1
      • Arkansas 1
      • California 4
      • Colorado 1
      • Connecticut 1
      • Delaware 1
      • Florida 28
      • Georgia 1
      • Hawaii 1
      • Idaho 1
      • Illinois 3
      • Indiana 1
      • Iowa 1
      • Kansas 1
      • Kentucky 1
      • Louisiana 1
      • Maine 1
      • Maryland 3
      • Massachusetts 1
      • Michigan 4
      • Minnesota 2
      • Mississippi 1
      • Missouri 1
      • Montana 1
      • Nebraska 1
      • Nevada 1
      • New Hampshire 1
      • New Jersey 3
      • New Mexico 1
      • New York 1
      • North Carolina 2
      • North Dakota 1
      • Ohio 5
      • Oklahoma 1
      • Oregon 1
      • Pennsylvania 6
      • Rhode Island 1
      • South Carolina 5
      • South Dakota 1
      • Tennessee 1
      • Texas 6
      • Utah 1
      • Vermont 1
      • Virginia/DC 3
      • Washington 3
      • West Virginia 1
      • Wisconsin 1
      • Wyoming 1
    • General 3
AA Anonymity Statement

Anonymity is the spiritual foundation of all our traditions.

Please respect this and treat in confidence who you see and what you hear.

About Silkworth.net
  • Privacy Policy
  • Legal Disclaimer
  • Contact Us
External Links
  • Free 12 Step Toolkit App
  • Free AA Apple Apps
  • Free AA Android Apps
  • Silkworth’s YouTube Channel
  • Alcoholics Anonymous (AAWS Inc.)
  • AA Grapevine, International Journal of Alcoholics Anonymous
  • Al-Anon Family (Includes Alateen)
Newsletter Subscription





  • © 2020 silkworth.net. All Rights Reserved